Don't Write Off Christmas: How to Own the Winter Slump
Will Dyson ·
Why the six weeks before Christmas don't have to be a write-off, how I decide between a small effort now and a bigger frustration in January, and how to set the minimum standards that keep you moving forward.
So It Begins… the Winter Slump
It's mid-November, and I can already see it in the check ins… Weekend tracking falling off, skipped sessions because it's dark and cold. A few of you are also watching the scale creep up and getting frustrated with it.
None of this is a surprise. When I looked at the training data in my coaching app, the average workouts per client per week fall from 3.9 in September to 3.0 in October and 2.7 so far this month. That’s roughly one in five sessions disappeared when comparing summer to winter so far.
The same thing happens every January. The second week rolls round and people realise they've spent two months going backwards or having made very little progress, causing them to conclude that “trying to be good over Christmas is pointless anyway” with the consolement equivalent to that of getting a long-awaited pay rise only to realise it has all been absorbed by tax. Usually, these kinds of articles end up resonating somewhat like this…
Gandalf
… but I assure you, like good old Gandalf, that my intention is not to be the fun police, but instead to help you strike the right balance of enjoyment and accountability, as ultimately; you are the driver and the one responsible for how you feel come January. I've written this mainly for my own clients, but if you've found it on the blog, it applies to you just as much.
Christmas Is… Sticky
The thing most people don’t appreciate - yet we all accept elsewhere in life - if that time is our most precious resource, as it’s the only one we can’t get back. Those two months of stalled of stalled/reverse progress, which then have to be clawed back in January before you can move forward again, end up being four months of time that you remain dissatisfied with where you’re at relative to your goals. That’s a third of the year…
The good news is that a small amount of attention goes a long way. In a Christmas trial in Birmingham, people who weighed themselves regularly and were given simple advice (such as how much activity it takes to burn off typical festive foods) lost a little weight over Christmas while the comparison group gained some. The difference between the groups was about half a kilo. The people in that trial still had their Christmas, but… with a plan and a bit more attention on what they were eating.
Again, for those that are clients of mine, this is why I hammer on about ensuring your food logs are complete, as just the simple act of awareness has a huge impact on our behaviours. I am forever the optimist, where I believe everyone knows what food choices are good and bad for us when the two options clearly presented to us; which the above study demonstrates beautifully. As such, this will be a theme throughout this article and the advice that follows.
Should We Sue Santa?
Whether you’re managing your own nutrition and training or if you have a coach, the most impactful thing you can do during this time is take ownership. The job of a coach is to give you a plan that's sustainable and fits your life well enough that you can apply it consistently; adjusting it as necessary when circumstances change and helping you plan around things like parties and travel. Sometimes things don’t always go to plan and get a little messy, which is also where having a coach in your corner helps you to re-navigate.
What they can't do is follow the plan for you. They’re not at your desk when the tin of Celebrations gets passed round… in not in your kitchen at 9 PM on a Saturday staring down the 7 different FOMO-purchased flavours of mince pies… Those decisions are yours, and so is what comes from them.
I'm saying this because I'd much rather you had the skills and foresight to handle Christmas well than the next 8 check ins being me copy and pasting the same “put down the mince pies…” response.
So if January arrives with more weight on the scale than you wanted, look at how you approached the plan and how much you followed before you think it’s the plan itself (something that should be done when hitting any roadblock, not just Christmas).
And now for the part where everyone switches off… “Moderation”.
Moderation comes from A) boundaries, B) that you've set for yourself and C) in advance about what's acceptable and what isn't; and nobody can set those for you.
Imagine if you just showed up for work at whatever time you chose. Would you expect to get paid just the same?
Whenever You Feel Unmotivated, Ask Yourself This…
Which would feel worse?
This is the lens I use for all of my own decisions. When I'm tempted to skip something, or overdo something, I ask myself which outcome would feel worse. The amount of times I wanted to quit my PhD because of just how many setbacks my research project had… but every time I came back to the same question “what would feel worse…
A) Giving in to the discomfort, listening to the stories that circled my brain like vultures daily, that I’m not good enough, that I could be earning 5 times the money I was, work a fraction of the hours in a job far more predictable and less stressful… but knowing that ultimately, I gave up and never realised the potential that everyone knew I had - and wanted to see -
B) Enduring <insert unexpected bullshit just as I thought I’d cracked it> but ultimately persisting through hardship after hardship, and having the unshakeable truth to know that over 7 years and countless challenges that pushed me to the edge of my limits mentally and psychologically; that I am capable, strong, and resilient, and achieved something that less than 1% of the population have.
I appreciate these reflections are deeply personal and won’t resonate with many, but this tool - along with incredible family, friends and even some clients that watched me walk the entire journey - is literally what let me hang on to the thread of hope that often felt mere nanometres in diameter.
It is powerful, and in this case:
On one side is getting to the second week of January having undone months of work, or having made no progress at all for two months.
On the other is the small, known cost of sticking to a few standards you’ve already agreed with yourself many times before.
When you put it like that, the decision usually makes itself…
Example 1: Wet Winter Walks
Most mornings I go for a 30-40 minute walk with my wife before work. In winter, in the UK, that obviously means getting wet a lot of the time.
The cost is half an hour of drizzle and perhaps getting a little soggy… But in return, my hips loosen off before a day I'll spend mostly sat at a desk, and I get to start the day outside with my wife before I get lost in my work.
The paradox is that if I skip it to stay dry and in the vain of doing more work, the time that I think I save only gets spent on extra mobility before I train, training with tight hips and the session feels like shit, my brain feeling more stretched from being stuck in accumulated work mode that little bit too long and missing out on the broader perspectives gained from peer conversation; all the while not having any of that quality time with my wife until the weekend effecting headspace and presence.
Put like that, a bit of rain is a pretty small price. “How do you think like that?” - I take the time to stop and think.
Example 2: The Danger Aisle
Every year the supermarket and the office fill up with weird and wonderful new mince pies (lookin’ at you, Aldi 😒…) and the knee-jerk is very much to feel like you have to try them all, right now, even though they'll be back next year and the year after that. However, if we do this cool “stop and think” thing, it gives Accountability that little bit of space to tap you on the shoulder and remind you that if you really can't bear to miss one, you can take a box home and freeze it.
But instead, the version plays more out like this…
We see a box out at work, nail three of them, one after another, in the middle of the workday while replying to emails, just because they’re there; with nothing in the day adjusted to make room for the calories. You barely remember eating them, they've still blown the day's calories, and are left feeling like another week's progress has gone.
There's a reason that happens. Across 24 studies, eating while distracted led people to eat more at that meal and even more later on, whereas paying attention to what you've eaten helped reduce later intake.
Take a second to stop and think about that. I mean really think about it. Try and describe how one of the mince pies you had last Christmas tasted, and crucially, why it was so special/revelatory Vs previous years’.
The accountable way to approach festive treats goes more like this… You check how many calories are in one (they're often well over 200 kcal each, so check the box) and pick the variety you think you’ll enjoy most. You make room for it in your day, then eat it when you can sit down and enjoy it properly. One mince pie, eaten on purpose and enjoyed, without any of the frustration afterwards.
Example 3: Christmas Drinks
If you're a social person with a few different friend groups, December can easily turn into a conveyor belt of Christmas drinks. Which, honestly, there are fewer greater blessings than feeling loved, valued and having connection. You should be seeing people, embracing those friendships, and making the most of it - “you can't take it with you”, after all, but you can take the memories.
However, what you don't need to do to enjoy people's company is turn every weekend into a booze fest. In fact, you don't need to drink alcohol at all to have a good time. Non-alcoholic beers, diet drinks, lime and soda - they're all right there, and it's worth challenging the default assumption that alcohol is an essential ingredient for a good night out at Christmas. And before anyone starts rolling their eyes thinking this is another holier than thou fitness fanatic living their best T-total life - I drink, and will say with shameless arrogance that I could also drink 99% of the readers under the table. I have a growing whisky collection. I grew up in the Western Cape, friends with head winemaker of Wildekrans (also William who, to my dismay in our social circle gained the title of “Big” Willy… guess who was left with the latter) - one of South Africa’s very best. I love a good drink… but I do so intentionally, and in moderation.
Again, it comes back to stopping and asking yourself: what do I actually want from this night?
What am I going to remember in a year's time?
Am I going to remember the third pint I had?
Or am I going to remember Paul telling that belter of a joke that had the whole table doubled over for five minutes?
Try this right now…
Grab a pen and write down one drink you ordered on a night out last Christmas - just one out of the entire festive period - and try to describe how it tasted. I'd bet good money you can't.
If you do fancy a drink, be intentional about it. Don't just order on autopilot because it's your round. Sit down, look at the menu, and decide in advance what you're actually going to enjoy. Instead of knocking back four cheap double G&Ts that you won't even remember - leaving you that bit more alcoholed and writing off the next day’s training before it's even started - pick one really nice cocktail and one decent double gin and slimline tonic, and savour them.
Interspace them with non-alcoholic drinks, and think about how long you actually want to be out. One to two hours is a perfectly meaningful amount of time to catch up with people you care about where you don’t need to go overboard. One or two well-chosen alcoholic drinks and a couple of soft drinks are more than enough to carry you through that, without the hangover, the blown calories, or the Sunday write-off.
A couple of little bonuses that might be useful to know, there are decent non-alcoholic options that don’t taste like soap/plastic, remarkably. Whitley Neill Rhubarb & Ginger 0% Gin is pretty damn good with a decent tonic (which has the bitterness/sharpness that alcohol usually contributes) that I would actually pay for in public. Brooklyn Special Effects (hoppy lager) is that good that I bought a case of 20 from Amazon. And finally, the Guinness alcohol free. I’m not a Guinness guy at all but it’s very close to authentic. With all of these, don’t drink them warm - nothing tastes good warm - ice cold. Always.
All three examples come down to deciding in advance what's acceptable, and then sticking to it.
Something > Nothing
Clearly, sticking to your prescribed meal plan that I’ve hand-tailored to your preferences, schedule and training, with an intentional, well-moderated and pre-meditated off plan meal (I don’t ban off plan meals for clients, ever) once or twice a week is always your best bet.
But what about when you haven’t meal prepped? When you’re wandering around the supermarket crippled so much by food noise and hunger that you just want to get out of there as quickly as possible?
Have a list.
Get a pen and paper out - now! - and write down five things that you know are healthy enough choices that you can get from a supermarket, that you can find in most supermarkets. The key here is the word “enough” - they don’t have to be perfect.
- A chicken salad sandwich and a protein yogurt (actually a great choice)
- A microwave tuna pasta bake (usually surprisingly good for macros)
- A pot of reduced fat hummus and some carrot sticks (not everything has to be about protein…)
These are just the first three things that popped into my head and, granted, I have 15 years in the game of nutrition coaching and - much to my wife’s dismay - pick up most things in the supermarket out of curiosity, leaving my brain like a nutritional encyclopedia… But herein lies a recurring theme - stop and think (and write them down).
There is always a better option than simply eating with your stomach and grabbing whatever sounds nicest that, again, you won’t remember 5 minutes after eating; but you will at the end of the week when you feel like you’ve spent another week on the hamster wheel for no progress. And the harsh reality is that that, will be entirely your fault.
Set Your Minimum Acceptable Standards
Zooming out from the day to day, aside from that, most useful thing you can do before December swallows you into it’s festive vortex of mulled doom, is decide what your minimum looks like. The standard you'll hold even when the diary's full and the weather's grim.
A good set of standards might include:
- Logging everything, every day, including weekends and including the days when the numbers are higher than usual.
- Hitting your protein target on most days.
- A minimum number of training sessions each week (for example, 3 if you'd normally do 4-5).
- A daily average step count that you'll hit even on the busiest weeks (doing more on weekends if weekdays are rammed).
- 7-8 hours sleep a night, every night (lack of sleep crushes willpower when it comes to appetite)
- Weighing yourself regularly, so the trend never surprises you and you can self-moderate as you go (it’s a lot harder to course correct when you’re miles off course).
- Planning the big meals and nights out in advance (send me your menus so we can traffic light as usual), then getting straight back to normal the next morning.
- Give yourself 30-60 minutes each day to let your brain decompress (willpower and executive function aren’t in endless supply, and a little headspace goes a long way).
Write them as if-then plans where you can "If mince pies come round at work, I'll have one after lunch and log it", or "If it's raining on my walk day, I'll wear the waterproof and go anyway.", or "If my husband keeps bringing home biscuits, I'll make sure I always have hummus and crudités so I have a healthier option."
Plans written this way have been shown to help people eat more healthily, with the strongest effect on adding healthy foods and a smaller but useful effect on cutting back on less healthy ones. Think about where you most commonly get tripped up and have some examples ready.
Then, decide what an acceptable (and realistic) outcome looks like by the second week of January. For some of you, that might be holding your weight steady. For others, it's keeping your training consistent while your weight drifts up slightly over the big days (but have a ceiling you’d be happy with - e.g. +1.5 kg). Whatever it is, decide it now, while you're thinking clearly, and write it down. Planning and pre-determination kill the negativity that come with the shock of “shit, I’ve gained 5 lbs!”.
Take Stock
For my coaching clients, this is why the quarterly review exists. It's where we audit our last three months - how well we’ve stuck to our plan, did we achieve what we wanted to? wins, room for improvement etc. - and map out the next three months together, including what an acceptable outcome looks like for you and the standards that get you there.
I know it's tempting to skip. It feels like admin with everything else going on before Christmas, so it's easy to tell yourself you'll do it in January, but the reality is that “knowing what you want” simply isn’t enough, as if the awareness of your bigger picture goal was all it took - I wouldn’t have a job. Doing this brief audit is one of the most useful things you'll do before the new year, because it's where you set your standards before December gets busy rather than in the middle of it.
If you're a client, you'll find it in the Forms section of the Coach. app (click on the gear icon on the dashboard). Please give it proper time and detail, because the more you put into it, the more useful my plan for your next three months will be.
If you're not a client, open your Notes app and answer the same questions:
- What would an acceptable outcome be by the second week of January?
- What are your minimum standards for training and food?
- Which events are coming up, and what's your plan for each one?
- What usually throws you off at this time of year, and what's your if-then plan for it?
Christmas Isn't Pointless
Enjoy it, and enjoy the food and the people. Just do it on purpose, with standards you've chosen in advance, rather than letting the next six weeks simply happen to you.
If you get to the second week of January having stuck to the standards you set, you'll start 2027 ahead of most people, and I'll be really pleased to see it in your check-ins.
Coach
P.s. Anyone reading this that isn’t already a client who needs advice around this period, I am taking on clients for 2027 intake and would love to help you navigate this period.
References
- Adriaanse et al.. Do implementation intentions help to eat a healthy diet? A systematic review and meta-analysis of the empirical evidence (PMID: 21056605). Appetite, 2011. Source
- Mason et al.. Effectiveness of a brief behavioural intervention to prevent weight gain over the Christmas holiday period: randomised controlled trial (PMID: 30530821). BMJ, 2018. Source
- Robinson et al.. Eating attentively: a systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect of food intake memory and awareness on eating (PMID: 23446890). Am J Clin Nutr, 2013. Source
- Yanovski et al.. A prospective study of holiday weight gain (PMID: 10727591). N Engl J Med, 2000. Source
This page needs JavaScript to work. Switch it on and reload, or jump to one of these.